How to help young people build resilience and confidence online
When you were growing up, you probably turned to your best friend or your diary when you needed to pour your heart out or share your insecurities – not to a global audience. But these days young girls may upload videos of themselves to public online forums in which they talk to the camera about their appearance and ask the question: ‘Am I pretty or ugly?’ or ‘How pretty am I?’
Why are ‘Am I pretty?’ videos and posts popular?
Search ‘Am I pretty?’ or ‘Am I ugly?’ online and you'll find millions of links to photos and videos of girls aged 9 to 13 asking these questions.
There are various theories as to why this trend has gone viral – boredom, attention-seeking, simple curiosity. However, one common thread is that these girls have often already been teased or bullied about their appearance offline – and have taken to the internet to confirm or negate it.
Cammy Nelson, a media literacy speaker and activist, says: “They’ve placed their self-esteem in the hands of the bigger world that is the internet. Twenty ‘Likes’ on a selfie is worth more than a compliment.”
Girls in their tweens and teens often feel anxious about their growing and changing appearance, especially if they’ve been bullied about it – and social media provides a ready-made platform for feedback. Unfortunately, that feedback can be negative as well as positive.
Who responds to ‘Am I pretty?’ videos?
These girls are inviting verdicts on their appearance and there are thousands of people willing to respond, often anonymously or under an alias. Louise Orwin, a UK performance artist keen to understand this phenomenon, uploaded ‘Am I pretty or ugly?’ videos to YouTube posing as three different teenage girls. She says: “I had assumed that most of my audience would be teenage girls; however, when I researched my commenters, I found that nearly 70% were men over the age of 18.”
Orwin describes receiving more than 4,000 comments – 70% of which were negative. Not only are these comments critical, but many are also cruel and hateful, pointing out specific physical attributes as unsightly. Others are sexual in nature, objectifying and sometimes inviting a response.
Protecting your daughter from the lure of the ‘Am I pretty?’ test
Aside from the threat of predators, research has shown a correlation between appearance-related teasing and body dissatisfaction. Unsurprisingly, an association also exists between negative weight-related comments and eating disorders.
Part of protecting your girl from these risks is being informed.
Staying on top of the latest technology and social media sites can be overwhelming, so talk to your daughter about her social media usage and who she's sharing photos and videos with.
Start a conversation about the ‘Am I pretty?’ test trend. Chances are she's heard of someone who's done it – or perhaps even tried it herself already. Discuss why posting an ‘Am I pretty or ugly?’ video, or seeking feedback about her body from strangers, can be harmful. See below for tips.
Explore what ‘beauty’ actually means
Remind her that beautiful women come in all shapes and sizes. Explain that what she looks like is only a small part of who she is and shouldn’t overshadow her skills and talents
View a few ‘Am I pretty?’ videos with your daughter
Start a discussion about why she thinks these girls are seeking approval from strangers. Express and encourage compassion for these girls and avoid being judgemental
Encourage your daughter to speak up
Ask her to tell you if she or a friend has been, or is being, bullied online. Reassure her that she won’t be in trouble and you only want to help
Don’t prevent her using social media
That could lead her to use it in ways where you can't monitor her. Instead, insist that you approve and can oversee any social media accounts she wants to set up
Make her aware of privacy settings on social media sites
Ensure she doesn’t share private information, such as her phone number or email address, in public
Talk to her about risks
Discuss the potential dangers of putting photos and videos of herself online – particularly those that, like the ‘Am I pretty’ test, involve her self-esteem. Remind her that, even if she deletes something, it may never be completely erased – even if it appears like it has been erased at the time
Is there anything else we can help you discover?
When it comes to your body, love the one you're with
Beauty is an all-ages show
Every body is beautiful
Be your beautiful self